fbpx
37.6 F
Spokane
Thursday, March 28, 2024
HomeCommentaryThe GOD who washes feet isn't the god atheists see

The GOD who washes feet isn’t the god atheists see

Date:

Related stories

Lost in Translation: Isn’t It Time We Moved Beyond a Fear-Based Repentance?

When I hear the kingdom is at hand, followed immediately by the command to repent, the good news is overshadowed by the fear that I’m not good enough to be part of the kingdom of God.

Inspiring Others: How Our Marriage Turned 50

As we prepare to celebrate 50 years there are so many thoughts and memories going through my head. I have joked about how I don't know how you've put up with me for this long, which is really true in a sense with my Irish enthusiasm and temper.

Taking the Road ‘Less Traveled by’ Has Made ‘All the Difference’

Pete Haug remembers hearing Robert Frost read his poem "The Road not Taken" 65 years ago. It reminded him of his spiritual journey out of the Christianity of his youth into choosing the Baha'i faith as an adult.

Ask an EOC: Can You Confess in Private to God but not in Church Confession and be Forgiven?

Concerning the sacrament of Confession, Christ directly gave the authority to his Church to remit or retain the sins of the penitent. 

Stuff: Do We Have Too Much? Depends on What Kind.

“Stuff” is one of those words in English that has so many meanings it almost defies definition.

Our Sponsors

spot_img
spot_img
Wikimedia commons image
Wikimedia commons image

Leading up to my turning 50, I reread the farewell discourse of Jesus found in John 13-17. As read it, I thought of many of new (gnu) atheists and my trouble with them. They, in reading them, describe a different god that I experience in Scripture and my life. Sam Harris, Richard Dawkins, Daniel Dennett, and Christopher Hitchens, the so-called Four Horsemen of the movement, all describe a god that made people mean and I can see why they would fight such a god. But like a wife being married to a wonderful spouse who is kind and thoughtful, and then suddenly being told that that person is in reality a rapist, murderer and torturer, and trying to square it with what she lives with each day, the disconnect makes no sense. Their god does not make sense to me, compared to the god every day.

The more I read in John 13-17, the more I felt this. The God that calls us to love one another is the God whose love was best expressed by foot washing.  I felt the presence of the Triune God as I reflected on this. Setting up for my party and greeting those that came to mourn the passing of my youth, the more God presented God self in the beauty of life. All became grace. In the eyes of people I love, I kept finding the living Jesus, resurrected and loving. I thank all who came and saw them as a gift from God. The truth of the Gospel, of God becoming man to save us from our own darkness was shown in the July sun as we shared stories and heard about each other’s life. Good food and Huckleberry Margaritas made the kindness of God real. In many ways I can see the point of the gnu atheists as they see a vengeful God demand worship.

If I experience a similar God, I too would fight that idol. Yet, as I turn into the long decline still full of life and as I watch my son grow and see the people in my life, I can feel the gentle hand of God washing the muck of my feet. I may have stepped in dung, but God is  washing it off. Love one another as I love you, Jesus sums up his Gospel before submitting to the violence of Rome, Empire and man’s vainglory that the cross represents. Love one another, triumphs over the violence of man.

Ernesto Tinajero
Ernesto Tinajero
Art, says Ernesto Tinajero, comes from the border of what has come before and what is coming next. Tinajero uses his experience studying poetry and theology to write about the intersecting borders of art, poetry and religion.

Our Sponsors

spot_img
spot_img
spot_img

5 COMMENTS

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Paul Susac
Paul Susac
9 years ago

Ernesto,

Reading your article, I was struck by both the eloquence of your words, and your deep misunderstanding of the atheist worldview. Atheism, as I practice it, is not a choice, but rather it is a consequence of a choice. I choose to apply basic standards of evidence-based reasoning to religious texts and teachings. In so doing, I come to the conclusion that magical, supernatural creatures (God, the devil, Jesus, the Angel that spoke to Mohammad, a flying Buddhist monk etc.) are not amenable to evidence, since their supernatural powers exempt them from the laws of cause and effect. I therefore conclude that human superstition is a more likely explanation for many biblical stories than is magic.

You think that we atheists oppose God. We do not. We oppose ignorance and self-deception. The story of Jesus is a way that humans have found to make sense of the world, but in our fearful desire for certainty, too many of us cling to these stories as if they are literally, historically true. What makes me an atheist is not that I deny the truth of these stories, but rather that I deny that these stories meet any meaningful standard of evidence by which one can measure truth.

Does this mean that these stories they have no value? No. Stories are among the most powerful tools that we humans use for creating meaning and value in our lives, but this is not the same thing as saying that the truth value of the claims of a story are beyond reproach, and so, as an atheist it is my duty to reproach them. THIS is the ignorance and self-deception that I oppose: It is ignorance and self-deception to believe that you hold knowledge when in fact you are deciding a story is true based on the political power it gives you, or the way it makes you feel. We humans are experts at self-deception, especially where our interests are concerned. This is true of me and it is true of you. Do no deny this.

This insight leads me to the same epistemological stance that most atheists take. This epistemological stance flows from a MORAL desire to avoid the harm that so often comes from holding wrong beliefs. Evidence based reasoning is the gold standard of human knowledge. Evidence-based knowledge is tentative, changeable and based on facts. What facts do we know about God?

1) We know for a fact that “God” is a word and like most words, the word “God” means different things to different people. What’s more, I have observed that for MANY people the word “God means different things to the SAME person at different times.
2) We know for a fact that the word God often refers to a character in a story, and that this character is reputed to have mysterious and magical powers
3) We know for a fact that many, many people take these stories about God very, very personally, but that there are many, many disagreements about this character.
4) We know for a fact that people like to divide themselves up into teams, tribes, organizations, congregations and nations based on which of these stories humans believe in or which of them they find important.
5) We know for a fact that people use these stories to justify power and privilege for themselves, often at the expense of others, and that people also use these stories to negotiate and make sense of their experience of themselves and of their relationship with their family and community.

If God exists as most Christians imagine him, he has magical superpowers, powers that allow him to ignore cause and effect. I am human though. I cannot ignore cause and effect. I MUST USE cause and effect to tell truth from falsehood. This is not a limit of your God, it is a limit on how human knowledge works. It is beyond the ability of reason to prove or disprove the existence of God.

If you look at my list of facts above, you might notice that very quickly, knowledge of God becomes knowledge of humanity. My best guess about this is that God is a reflection of humanity. An expression of an unconscious need to subjugate ourselves to a loving parental figure. I find it comforting to know that so many people worship a loving God as opposed to the wrathful old sociopath in the Old Testament. I suppose that’s a form of human moral progress of a sort, although one might argue that the New Testament idea of hell erases all the good that the story of Jesus has done and more.

It is NOT beyond the ability of reason to explain BELIEF in God however. Belief is a human psychological state, and one that many people use to take comfort, build community and obtain political and economic power. It is this political and economic power that we atheists oppose. After all, how often have believers in one god or another rationalized away their violent behavior on the basis of their divine justification? How often are non-believers excluded from conversation, debate or privileged status? How often do we assume that people who believe differently than us are morally our inferiors?

Your description of the foot washing comes down to two things that I can identify with – Absolution and Humility. It may surprise you to learn that I have practices that I use for both of these needs, and that I engage in these practices without a relationship to a divine authority figure. I practice apology and forgiveness, and I practice making amends. Through these practices I seek and find absolution.

As for humility, you say your God humbles himself by washing the feet of his followers. How would it humble you to admit that you CANNOT know that your God exists? It is vanity to say that you know something that you cannot know. This is the insight that leads to atheism. Belief in God is vanity. Humility is the soul of atheism.

Frank Bender
Frank Bender
9 years ago

Nice reply and insight Paul Susac.

Mark N
Mark N
9 years ago

During my years as an “Agnostic”, I resented God’s power and the requirement of submission to such strength. I was created in God’s image, and thus possess a measure of egocentric views I have yet to earn. Not until I witnessed the birth of a child gifted to me by Our Lord did I finally comprehend a power so great, and so generous, as the one who allowed me a place in the generations of God’s Universe. Thanks be to God.

spot_img
5
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x