Story of Jesus by Gaudenzio Ferrari

Father Knows Best: Do you think the Gospels were editorialized?


By Martin Elfert

Do you have a question about life, love, or faith? Submit it online, fill out the form below or email it to melfert@stjohns-cathedral.org.

Hey Readers!

Two weeks back, I advised Anthony — a young man who doesn’t like to dance and who likes his girlfriend’s interest in dancing even less — to go hit the dance floor. My friend Ken wrote me with a great piece of additional advice for Anthony: before you go, take a hip-hop class. 

I spent a lot of years saying, “I can’t sing.” And then I started practicing singing. And what do you know? I found out that I actually have a voice. I suspect that a lot of us who say, “I can’t dance,” might be stuck in a similar place. If we actually practiced dancing, who knows what kind of moves we might discover?

And now, this week’s question:

House-ad_SPO_FKB_new_0429139Hey Rev!

Do you think the Gospels were editorialized?

– Tad Iodize Lire

Dear Tad:


While there are substantial commonalities between the four Gospels, the authors of each had a set of themes about who Jesus was (and who Jesus is) that they were especially interested in emphasizing. The examples of those themes are numerous — exploring even a few of them is the project of a book rather than a 700-word column – so I’ll confine myself to a brief “for instance.” It’s a “for instance” that we find right at the beginning: Jesus’ birth narrative.

For Matthew, one of the really important themes in Jesus’ birth and early life is that this time fulfilled the expectations of the Old Testament. Thus, Matthew’s account is filled with what we might call citations from the Jewish Bible. These citations generally begin with some variation on the words, “this took place in order to fulfill what had been spoken by the prophet.” So, the news that Mary is a virgin is followed by a quotation from Isaiah, the news that Jesus will be born in Bethlehem is followed by a quotation from Micah, and the account of Herod’s murder of the innocents is followed by a quotation from Jeremiah.

For Luke, by contrast, one of the really important things for us to know about Jesus’ birth and early life is that this time announced that God is to be found in the most unexpected of places and among the most unexpected of people. Thus, the first few chapters of Luke establish what some scholars call a “counter-narrative” to the story that we expect to hear. We expect a king to be born into luxury: the newborn Jesus sleeps a manger, an old-school word that basically means “trough.” We expect the news of a king to be announced in court: it is announced to peasants caring for livestock. We expect wisdom to be found with well-trained elders: it is found in a 12-year-old boy.

Mark figures that the important news about Jesus begins when Jesus is a grown-up, and so the second Gospel has no birth narrative at all. And John is similar — the fourth Gospel looks to the time before Jesus’ adulthood only long enough to proclaim that the Word that became flesh in Jesus was with God since the very beginning.

There are lots of opportunities, Tad, to explore more about how each of the Gospels tells the story of Jesus. An old but still really cool resource is what is variously called a “harmony” or a “synopsis.” This is a book in which similar passages from one or more of the Gospels are printed in columns beside one another. A synopsis allows you to easily look at the different word choices that each of the authors makes, the different details that each adds or subtracts. And it allows you to easily find the elements that are unique to a given Gospel.

An even better way of learning is to take a class. If you live near a seminary or a university with a Biblical Studies department, go and enroll in “Introduction to the New Testament.” I bet that you will learn a bunch about Jesus. And I bet that you will be inspired by the extraordinary work that the authors of the Gospels did in editing Jesus’ story and passing it on to us.

About Martin Elfert

The Rev. Martin Elfert is an immigrant to the Christian faith. After the birth of his first child, he began to wonder about the ways in which God was at work in his life and in the world. In response to this wondering, he joined Christ Church Cathedral in Vancouver, British Columbia, where he and his new son were baptized at the Easter Vigil in 2005 and where the community encouraged him to seek ordination. Martin served on the staff of the Episcopal Cathedral of St. John the Evangelist in Spokane, Wash. from 2011-2015. He is now the rector of Grace Memorial Episcopal Church in Portland, Oreg.

View All Posts

Check Also

Gay pride flags should not be banned in classrooms

I agree that in general, classrooms shouldn't be a place to push a particular political ideology or campaign. However, simply being gay in school isn't a political campaign. It's a recognition that a teacher's classroom is a safe place for gay kids. If that's political to you, even if the teacher never once mentions a political candidate, you've probably got a problem with the existence of the gay kids.

One comment

  1. A reader left this as a FKB Question, but meant to leave it as a comment, so I’m moving it to the correct place:

    “Read The Life and Teachings of Jesus as written in The Urantia Book.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.