fbpx
45.5 F
Spokane
Thursday, March 28, 2024
HomeCommentaryCecil, mob mentality, and the fallen world

Cecil, mob mentality, and the fallen world

Date:

Related stories

My Journey through Homelessness Part Five: Learning to Live Outside the Box

The value of my homeless experience lies not so much in having learned how to live outside — at least not in the geographical sense. The value of my homeless experience lies in having learned how to live outside the box.

Lost in Translation: Isn’t It Time We Moved Beyond a Fear-Based Repentance?

When I hear the kingdom is at hand, followed immediately by the command to repent, the good news is overshadowed by the fear that I’m not good enough to be part of the kingdom of God.

Inspiring Others: How Our Marriage Turned 50

As we prepare to celebrate 50 years there are so many thoughts and memories going through my head. I have joked about how I don't know how you've put up with me for this long, which is really true in a sense with my Irish enthusiasm and temper.

Taking the Road ‘Less Traveled by’ Has Made ‘All the Difference’

Pete Haug remembers hearing Robert Frost read his poem "The Road not Taken" 65 years ago. It reminded him of his spiritual journey out of the Christianity of his youth into choosing the Baha'i faith as an adult.

Ask an EOC: Can You Confess in Private to God but not in Church Confession and be Forgiven?

Concerning the sacrament of Confession, Christ directly gave the authority to his Church to remit or retain the sins of the penitent. 

Our Sponsors

spot_img
spot_img

By Neal Schindler

A few days ago, in response to the Cecil the lion/Walter Palmer story, I posted the following status on Facebook: “As someone who cares a lot about animals, I understand where the rage toward Walter Palmer is coming from. But hunting and killing him isn’t going to happen and wouldn’t bring Cecil back. I do think he deserves some serious jail time and a fine that hits like Thor’s hammer.” I wrote this because I had visited a news website where the comments thread devolved quickly into rhetorical vigilantism. Then I came across a persuasive article by Max Fisher, entitled “From Gamergate to Cecil the lion: internet mob justice is out of control.” This piece led me, in turn, to Jon Ronson’s fantastic exploration of Justine Sacco’s 15 minutes of infamy back in 2013.

I’m Jewish, but I spend enough time around Christians to have a rudimentary understanding of a few Christian concepts. I’ve often heard Christians describe our world as “broken” and “sinful,” based on the fall of man. When I think of human error, of our deeply imperfect nature, I tend to think of how horrifically we mistreat animals.

Yes, the animal kingdom is a wild place of hunting and killing and eating. In the natural world, death is, indeed, ubiquitous. And yes, the strong generally dominate the weak. But among animals there is also concern for group welfare. There is pack loyalty, and parents protect their young. Dearly departed Cecil’s brother is expected by wildlife experts to keep Cecil’s offspring safe, because it’s what lions do. It’s what’s best for Cecil’s bloodline — essentially, for his family.

It’s instinct, of course. But some sizable part of our own parental tendencies has to be instinct, too. As time passes, I see less and less benefit to thinking of humans as radically different from other animals. Some theologies tell us we have dominion over all other species, like born rulers over their subjects. That arrogant mindset has led to pollution, global warming, factory farming, and illegally poached lions.

I stand by what I wrote on Facebook. Keyboard warriors and in-person activists alike can assault Walter Palmer’s well-being and that of his family, but none of it will bring Cecil back, advance the cause of animal rights, or shut down poaching. My personal belief is that hunting for sport is not inherently moral. Reducing an animal population as mercifully as possible for that population’s own benefit is one thing. So is respectful hunting for needed meat among robust animal populations that can withstand the culling. But animal heads on walls, and that iconic photo of Ernest Hemingway smiling beside a dead lion, bring to my mind only the worst qualities that human beings possess.

I’ve heard people say that Palmer had no idea that what he was doing was illegal. On an emotional level, this strikes me as a tremendously unsatisfying explanation. I hope Palmer’s alleged ignorance doesn’t shield him from legal punishment for what he did. But what matters more than Palmer’s fate is whether Cecil’s death nudges the animal-rights movement further into the mainstream.

The other day I received an envelope inviting me to rejoin the Sierra Club. On the front was a picture of a dead wolf in the snow. I had two thoughts at once: 1) This is emotional manipulation, and 2) It’s totally working on me. I have a soft spot for wolves, especially since a fear-mongering local billboard campaign irresponsibly portrayed them as bloodthirsty killers of children.

My energy isn’t going into wishing Walter Palmer ill. That kind of thinking seems like time and emotion misspent. I’m trying instead to focus on how I can more authentically live out my values as a deeply imperfect human who wants to do right by his countless fellow beings.

Neal Schindler
Neal Schindler
A native of Detroit, Neal Schindler has lived in the Pacific Northwest since 2002. He has held staff positions at Seattle Weekly and The Seattle Times and was a freelance writer for Jew-ish.com from 2007 to 2011. Schindler was raised in a Reconstructionist Jewish congregation and is now a member of Spokane's Reform congregation, Emanu-El. He is the director of Spokane Area Jewish Family Services. His interests include movies, Scrabble, and indie rock. He lives with his wife, son, and two cats in West Central Spokane.

Our Sponsors

spot_img
spot_img
spot_img

2 COMMENTS

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Nabil
Nabil
8 years ago

Neal – do you think this Cecil the Lion thing was overrated at all? I mean, poaching is terrible, it is. But there are other issues – human issues – we should putting our energy into. Right? Or does it all go connect somehow?

Neal Schindler
Neal Schindler
8 years ago

Wel, I think the following article has a perspective worth considering:

http://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/08/05/opinion/in-zimbabwe-we-dont-cry-for-lions.html?referrer=

After reading this I felt as I though had been pretty poorly informed before reading it.

However, cruel and unusual punishment isn’t okay, even if lions are killers. There’s no need for an animal to suffer for 40 hours.

spot_img
2
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x