Ask An Evangelical: Forsake your family?

Share this story!
  • 8

What do you want to know about Evangelicalism? Submit your question here.

By Scott McIntyre

Why is it that Evangelicals speak of Christian family values when Jesus said that you must hate and forsake your family?  

To set the stage, our questioner provided Luke 14:26 and Matthew 19:29 as references to this question, and in Bible translations such as the King James, English Standard, and New International, the word ‘hate’ is front and center when describing the relationship between Jesus’ followers and their families.  The New International Version has Jesus saying: “If anyone comes to me and does not hate father and mother, wife and children, brothers and sisters—yes, even their own life—such a person cannot be my disciple.”

Elsewhere in Scripture, though, we find commands, also attributed to Jesus, to ‘love’ one another, your neighbor, and even your enemies. Are Evangelicals following those commands while ignoring Jesus’ words to hate their families or is there some other explanation for the hate-love references?

To come up with my answer, I reviewed what I’d learned through years of reading the Bible for myself, attending Bible studies, and listening to sermons, and did some current online research.

In the Christian learning circles I’ve frequented, loving the people around us has always been taught as God’s great commandment to humanity and that ‘hating’ family had to do with where we placed them on the food chain of loyalty.  For instance, if my wife says she needs me to help her get revenge on a nasty neighbor, I have to choose, instead, to do what I think Jesus would have me do, and let her manage the payback issue on her own.

My internet investigation yielded a lot of information and my favorite take on the question was in a commentary by Intervarsity Press.  The Luke passage tells us our hate should be directed toward a long inventory of family members, but according to their explanation of the verse, “the point of the list is that no other relationship is first for a disciple. “Hate” is used figuratively and suggests a priority of relationship. Jesus is first.”

Using the search phrase, commentary on luke 14 25-35, Google returned 140,000 results, and reviewing the first ten, I found eight that provided similar explanations to the above mentioned commentary.  I also located some Bible versions that, using slightly different language for the Luke passage, support the same idea.

For instance, The International Children’s Bible translates it this way: “If anyone comes to me but loves his father, mother, wife, children, brothers, or sisters more than he loves me, then he cannot be my follower.”

Even if I hadn’t found the many evidences to support what I came into the question believing, there would be one very practical reason why Jesus’s choice of such strong language should not be taken literally as a command to hate; hating someone is to easy.

Jesus was raising the bar for people who wanted to follow him.  He had high expectations and desired people to be all in.  So why demand a behavior that’s easy to live?  We all know that hate is too prevalent in many areas of our culture, and if we’re honest, we can probably find some of it in our own heart.  It doesn’t take much effort to hate.  Love on the other hand; giving, giving, giving without ever expecting anything in return; can be the hardest thing anyone ever does.

It seems logical to me that Jesus would want his followers to show their commitment to him through the difficult labor of love rather than an all too natural inclination toward hate.

About Scott McIntyre

Scott McIntyre is glad his parents didn’t name him Vladimir or he’d be listed last on this page. While a long time California resident, he was the Oakland Spirituality Examiner for from 2011-12 and about the same time began blogging on several topics. The first, teaching Christians how to lovingly share their spiritual beliefs, emphasized skills that can benefit all forms of one-to-one interaction. He also writes on marriage, travel, downsizing, humor, and the motive behind people’s words and actions. After retiring in 2016, Scott embarked on some major ‘R & R’; Relocating and Rebranding. Following in his sister’s footsteps from the early 80’s, and later in the decade, his parent’s, Scott left the Golden State to become a Washingtonian in a small town just west of Spokane County.

View All Posts

Check Also

Inequities in How We View Homelessness, Part 3

A young person said to me once: "I would have no idea what to say to a homeless person." "That's easy," I replied.  "Talk to them about anything except homelessness."

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *