What do you want to ask an Atheist? Fill out the form below or submit your question online.
By Jim Downard
If there was not a creator then how did everything come from nothing..just a big bang?
That is the ultimate “Origins or Bust” question, but it builds on implicit assumptions.
First, is “nothing” an option? What is meant by that? What science can tell us is that all the observable universe dates back to around 13.8 billion years ago, and commenced in a burp when the matter/energy/spacetime we can see originated. But from what? Need it have originated from anything? Why can’t universe itself be an Uncaused Cause? There’s no Manual of Stuff to preclude that.
And of course the moment one asks where the “creator” came from (and was there just the one?) the believer is liable to pull the plug and deny the question has any validity. More “Origins or Bust.”
But it’s just as easily imagined that there were a committee of gods, who may or may not have been immortal or omnipotent (and no rules on all on whether they need to be moral or even likable), one or more of whom engaged in creating “stuff.” And did they have any restrictions on that? “Stuff” only being hadrons and leptons, as opposed to squiggle-fop that is perpendicular to purple on Tuesdays? In other words, is the universe we have with physical dimensions and stuff that obeys laws nobody in any religious document ever tumbled upon, the only one possible?
By now we’re way into speculation, but that’s where we began, the moment we start speculating on what (if anything) existed “before” timespace and whether any entities were (or even could have been) involved.
Expect others to keep asking those questions, though. Just don’t expect any resolution to it any time soon, or maybe even ever.
- Ask An Atheist: Did Jesus Christ Exist? - June 13, 2019
- Ask An Atheist: What Are The Concrete Beliefs of Atheists? - May 5, 2019
- Ask An Atheist: Reincarnation - March 31, 2019
- Ask An Atheist: Is homosexuality logical? - March 17, 2019
- Ask An Atheist: Defining Life - March 9, 2019
- Ask An Atheist: Don’t you have to acknowledge God to deny God? - March 2, 2019
- Ask An Atheist: Explaining without offending - February 22, 2019
- Interfaith For All—When you like it … and even more when you don’t - February 10, 2019
- Ask An Atheist: How did everything come from nothing? - January 28, 2019
- Ask An Atheist: What Does Civility Look Like? - December 6, 2018