Spokane Faith & Values

Culture » Social Issues

Journalists hear concerns on fair reporting about Israel

Show Caption |

Display at Adas Israel Synagogue in Washington, D.C. Credit: Tracy Simmons

WASHINGTON -- Reporting on the “enormously sensitive” subject of Israel requires an extra dose of journalistic basics if coverage is going to be fair and balanced, according to a panel of experts involved in U.S.-Israeli programs.

Speaking on Thursday to members of the Religion Newswriters Association at Washington’s renowned Adas Israel Synagogue, moderator Rabbi David Saperstein reminded reporters of such foundational journalism practices as “don’t make mistakes,” “make sure the Israeli position is always heard,” and “be careful of loaded language.”

Few issues are as delicate for reporters as Israeli politics and events, Saperstein said.

He cautioned against quoting two opposing opinions, one from each extreme, while ignoring the majority of people in the middle.

Melanie Nezer of the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society said the current African migrant crisis in Israel is a good example of how reporting on Israel can be incomplete or superficial.

More than 60,000 Africans, mostly from Eritrea and Sudan, have crossed illegally into Israel, and their presence has drawn protests.

Those protests have made global news with some Israelis calling the Africans a “cancer” and other “ugly stuff,” Nezer said, but at the same time there are Israeli individuals and nonprofit groups that have provided food, shelter and other support to the migrants, Nezer said.

While the media are properly holding Israel accountable for the anti-migrant rhetoric, reporters should “look beyond just what the words are” and write about the actions of those who are helping the Africans, Nezer said.

Naomi Paiss of the New Israel Fund, reminded journalists that Israel is “an extraordinarily diverse identity and community.”

The range of beliefs among Jews about Israel is very, very wide, she said, and there are only two consensus points: Israel should exist and it should be secure.

Steve Krubiner of J Street, a Washington-based “pro-Israel, pro-peace” organization, urged reporters to consider the source when interviewing people about Israel. Even elected Israeli officials don’t necessarily speak for the majority of the population, he said.

He also illustrated the potential pitfalls of loaded language by citing a news article that was translated from Hebrew into Arabic. The original report contained the term “Israeli Defense Forces,” while the Arabic translation called it  “Zionist occupation forces.”

Saperstein and the other panelists said one of the most contentious topics in reporting on Israel today is the Palestinian-led “BDS” movement – for Boycott, Divest, Sanctions.

Paiss said BDS can be a legitimate too for change, as when it helped end Apartheid in South Africa. But she believes it is inaccurate when the media draws a parallel between Israel’s treatment of Palestinians and the racial discrimination that had existed in South Africa.

Krubiner said “the platform of the international BDS movement does not recognize the existence of the state of Israel,” and that J Street believes it “assigns blame unfairly to one side.”

He called for more public debate on issues raised by the BDS movement.

During a question-and-answer session, Krubiner said he does not welcome support for Israel from U.S. Christian groups such as evangelist John Hagee’s Citizens United For Israel, saying, “ultimately it doesn’t end well for Jews.”

Topics: Culture, Social Issues
Beliefs: Judaism
Tags: israel, jewish, jewish and israel, reporting on israel

You must acquire rights to repost our content. Log in now for permission to download and reprint or repost this article.

Comments

  1. WHOA…hold the press, say WHAT?

    “During a question-and-answer session, Krubiner said he does not welcome support for Israel from U.S. Christian groups such as evangelist John Hagee’s Citizens United For Israel, saying, “ultimately it doesn’t end well for Jews.”

    Is he going to explain that “LOADED” comment please?

  2. Eric, great question and it’s one I should have asked Mr. Krubiner at the event, but I did follow up today by email. He said he has two reasons for opposing some evangelical Christians’ support of Israel, one theological—that their motivation sometimes hinges on certain biblical end times prophecies that are negative to Jews and Israel—and the other political because some U.S. evangelical groups financially support settlements that, Krubiner said, “to my mind, undermines Israel’s future as a secure, democratic homeland for the Jewish people.”

  3. I guess, as a Christian who has been in evangelical circles most of my Christian life, I find his statements offensive.

    Some of Israel’s biggest supporters in this country are republican, conservative evangelical Christians. As a peace activists leaning pastor, I’ve rarely heard support for Palestinians in evangelical circles. From most conversations I’ve ever engaged in on these matters, you’d think most people are unaware of any other issues in the region but Israel.

    I think his last comments undermined his argument.

Add Your Comment

In the number 3376302, what is the 7th digit?

Related Stories

Spokane rabbi: Two holy days neglected by many American Jews

“Oh! Rabbi, we don’t do these minor ones. I don’t even know really what they are.”
More | Comments (0)

Professor to present “Film as Theology”

Sometimes the silver screen is more effective than the pulpit. The narratives found in cinema send strong theological messages, said Matthew S. Rindge, assistant professor of religious studies at Gonzaga University.
More | Comments (0)

Being Jewish in Spokane

Back when I lived in Seattle, I wrote for a blog called Jew-ish.com. My editor there, Leyna Krow, moved to Spokane in the fall of 2010 for graduate school. A few months later, she posted a brief essay titled “Feeling way too Jewish in Spokane."
More | Comments (1)

All you’ve ever wanted to know about the Hebrew year system but were afraid to ask

It took me a very long time to understand the year in the Jewish or Hebrew calendar and what it represents. As a child when my parents told me, usually at Rosh Hashanah, what year it was in the Hebrew calendar, I always came away with a sense of befuddlement.
More | Comments (0)

Kosher food pantries report growing need

As the director of a kosher food pantry outside Detroit, Lea Luger knows that some people have a hard time thinking that Jews anywhere in America could be short on food. “For many years, one of our biggest hurdles was convincing Jews and non-Jews that a need existed,” said Luger, executive director of Yad Ezra, which serves 1,400 families a month, up from 250 a month when the pantry was founded in 1990.
More | Comments (0)

Sign In



Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter