Spokane Faith & Values

Blogs » Viewpoints

VIEWPOINTS: Should women be allowed to fight in combat?

With women being involved in more and more combat situations in the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan for years, the Pentagon recently decided to rescind its 1994 policy banning women in combat that kept them from holding about 230,000 combat positions in the military.

A study last year from researchers at the San Francisco VA Medical Center and the University of California, San Francisco, found that female veterans reported the same rate of post-traumatic stress disorder as male veterans.

Read the full Viewpoints question here or continue on to the response below.

“War is hell”

If a woman is physically and emotionally capable of the rigors of combat, she should be given the opportunity to serve. I say that with a huge caveat, though. Gen. Sherman was right when he said that "war is all hell." This is not something we should do just so we can all brag about how "progressive" we are as a nation, nor is it something that should be done just to be politically correct. It should be carefully studied and done in a way that ensures the mission, whatever it is, can be accomplished. We're not just talking about some philosophical point, we're talking about people's lives. Those who have never served or seen combat have no clue what it's like.

Topics: Culture, Gender & Sexuality
Beliefs: Christian - Protestant/Other
Tags: women and combat

Other Responses to This Viewpoint

Learning from the women’s movement

This question has been asked for years within our culture. The one constant has been that American men have found it their job to “protect” our women, as much as possible, from the horrors and physical depravities of war.
More | Comments (0)

Keeping women from combat is unethical

The fact that we are still arguing about this says something deeply disturbing about our culture. While serving in the military is not my idea of a fulfilling career, it is for many people, including many women.
More | Comments (0)

The conversation shouldn’t be about gender

This is just a rehash of the Victorian argument that women should not be allowed to work outside of the home in order to protect them from the corrupt male industrial world...
More | Comments (0)

Comments

  1. Joe, I wanted to say thank you for your emotional maturity shown at the last Coffee Talk. When you were rebuffed in public in a manner that was rude, you didn’t respond in a unkind way. That was honorable.

    I know you are a man whose committed to his positions with passion and I admire that value. You also seem to be fine with others showing that too by your lack of aggression or defense.

    It’s tough throwing human cats and dogs in a room and prevent hissing and barking. I think we all do pretty good considering our cultures love for a fight.

    We all can learn how to be better people through our engagement with each other. Respect, deference, humility, being quick to hear & slow to speak, boldness and gentleness all have a role in work to craft a diverse thinking and believing community.

    You add to that goal.

    Our friend had a good point in his critique and I think we all need to work at figuring out how to do this community work with open hearts and hands without bring required to pretend we don’t disagree. It’s tough.

    Thanks for trying, when we fail or stumble lets keep getting up and moving forward.

    I’m just offering my hand.

  2. Personally, Joe, I thought it was pretty mean what some in the audience said to you. Props for toughing it out. It took guts, I know. :-)

  3. Thanks for the kind words, guys, appreciate you both very much!

Add Your Comment

Enter the largest number of 40, forty one, 95, eleven, 26 or 26:

Sign In



Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter