Spokane Faith & Values

Blogs » Ernesto Tinajero - Faith Expressions

Every crowded blog has a silver lining

Show Caption |

Barnum Circus Credit: Wikipedia

The rumors flew. Many hoped they were not true as most parents dream of normal children. P.T. Barnum saw something different for his distant cousin. He had visions of dollar signs. Soon, he talked his cousins into letting him teach the little boy to sing and dance. Two careers were born out of the fateful meeting. Tom Thumb would only grow to 3’8” and become a hero to many little people. He carried himself with dignity and respect. Barnum would start his career as the founder of modern American marketing. It is Barnum who continues to mark our culture.

Yes, we all remember Barnum as the founder of the famous circus. Yet as I reflect on the latest Mark Driscoll Ballyhoo, and know there will more Driscoll ballyhoos, I thought of a quote by Barnum which defines our young Pastor Driscoll along with many others both in and out of faith, “I don't care what you say about me, just spell my name right.”

Early last month there was a Facebook post by the young hero pastor and fighter for the maleness of Calvinism, asking from his friends for remembrances of effeminate male worship leaders. For those not familiar with Driscoll and his ministry, he preaches a brand of muscular Christianity that borders on cartoonish. Jesus was a man’s man, and had no time for silly girl stuff. Certainly no group kumbaya singing at Driscoll’s campsite. Today, Jesus would be, if not an NFL linebacker, surely an ultimate fighter. I always find it interesting that many of the leaders of such a vision of Christianity look like guys bullied in school. It is almost like they want Jesus to be like the guys that used to bully them. This, of course, should be for another time as to ponder why.

Of course the usual suspects came out to declare him lacking in love. He removed it with neither a comment by him nor an excuse or even, dare I say it, apology. Though before it was removed, it had 87 likes and counting. One day it was here and the next gone. The storm continued. Over on Religious Rhetoric they saw this as a case in which Facebook restrained the good pastor Driscoll. I take it as further evidence that Driscoll has learned the lessons of Barnum. Like Barnum, he knows that all publicity is good publicity. He knows that many of the same people that he stirs up are ones that others despise. People will be both turned off and turned on by his message.

Rachel Held Evans, no stranger to drawing attention, was one of the first to pounce. And then others pounce on her pouncing. Soon, the Internet was abuzz and all involve got a bump in hits and readership. Outrage raged on both sides. So, what to think of the whole affair? Or the many like it? Ah, as the grandmaster of promotions, our infamous Burnham would say, “There’s a sucker born every minute.”

Topics: Faith, Leaders & Institutions
Beliefs: Christian - Protestant/Other

Comments

  1. What “biblical” Christianity means today is reading my own values into the Bible rather than seriously trying to understand what the Bible says with help from the church fathers and academic theologians.

  2. Interesting. You’re right, he got the attention, negative or otherwise.

    I am interested, though, in the underlying stance that the church is not manly enough. I have heard it said before.

    What do you think the church should do to reclaim its masculinity while still remaining respectful?

  3. The idea that Christianity should be shaped by a (distinctly Anglocentric) view of masculinity goes back quite a ways. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muscular_Christianity

  4. The idea that Christianity should be shaped by (a distinctly Anglocentric view of) masculinity goes back quite a ways and has had an enormous influence in shaping the modern world. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muscular_Christianity

  5. Thanks guys for the responses.

    Amy,
    I think that the underlining issue for those that claim the church is not manly enough, the modern version that is, is an uncertainty about what it means to be a man in the culture at large. Unlike the historical muscular Christianity that had no sense of insecurity, the ones like Mark Driscoll often have a fear and uncertainty to them. It is one thing to advocate for the building of a strong body they way traditional Muscular Christianity.and quite another to use the other in terms of Effeminate worship leaders to build you version of being a man, a definition of not being rather than being.

    “I am a man, because I am not like ...” Driscoll writes large his own fears and uncertainties of being a man. Funny, he does not much talk about virtues like courage, loyalty, honor, and duty the traditional virtues of the good life.

    It is also surprising in that this is a modern American issue. Jesus did not go around saying what a real man was, nor did anyone else in the ancient world. The question was settled and known. It was what constitutes a good life.

    Maybe we should worry less about being manly and more about instilling courage, loyalty, honor and duty.

  6. “Maybe we should worry less about being manly and more about instilling courage, loyalty, honor and duty.”

    I don’t disagree at all! I would like to add that females can exhibit and excel at the very same values. The most courageous person I personally know is female.

  7. “I don’t disagree at all! I would like to add that females can exhibit and excel at the very same values. The most courageous person I personally know is female.”

    That is exactly right. If worried less about being men and more about being followers of Christ, then we sidestep those issues and be authentic humans formed by the grace of God.

  8. There was an interesting discussion about manliness at the New York Times (http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2012/07/12/are-modern-men-manly-enough). Some of the panelists talk about the humorous side of manliness (or lack thereof), but Lawrence Schlossman, one of the panelists, makes the argument that manliness doesn’t have to do with outward appearance, or as Ernesto points out, because of what a person is not. Rather, he says, “How about being a good guy, a good person. Just be honest, kind, tolerant, open, intrepid, self-aware, inquisitive, etc. — you know, all the things that have made our greatest men (and greatest anyone) great when we boil it down.”  And as Sam observed, this is not limited to men, either.

  9. Personally, the part about Christianity and Jesus’ teachings is the part where it’s about being a truly good, truly authentic human being, without worrying about conforming to an artificial image. It’s about being “naked” before the creator of the universe who made you the way you are, and learning to treat each other with decency inside that place of ultimate freedom.

Add Your Comment

Which of 51, forty two or 5 is the lowest?

Sign In



Forgot Password?

You also can sign in with Facebook or Twitter if you've connected your account to them.

Sign In Using Facebook

Sign In Using Twitter